New York's COPA Law: What Every Real Estate Agent Should Know
The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA) is a New York City law that gives city-approved nonprofits the first chance to buy certain distressed apartment buildings before the owner can sell on the open market.
By Joaquin Gutierrez, Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker (BK0625118) · Founder, JGRES · 30+ years in South Florida real estate
COPA requires owners of covered New York City apartment buildings to notify the city before selling. Approved nonprofits then get 20 days to express interest and 70 days to make an offer. The owner may reject the offer, but the nonprofit can match a later outside offer within 15 days. Violations can cost up to 15% of the sale price.
- Full name: Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, New York City Council Int. 905-A.
- Signed: November 10, 2026, by Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Lead sponsor: Council Member Sandy Nurse.
- Effective: one year after enactment (November 2027), following HPD rulemaking.
- Who gets the first shot: nonprofits and certain joint ventures approved by the NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD).
- What it covers: buildings with four or more units that meet a distress test, and buildings with 100 or fewer units under HPD affordability agreements.
Why a Florida agent should care about a New York City law
Three reasons. First, your clients. South Florida is full of buyers, sellers, and investors who own New York property or who are moving capital out of New York. When they ask you about COPA, your answer shapes how they see your competence.
Second, timing. A New York owner who plans to sell a covered building and reinvest in Miami-Dade, Broward, or Palm Beach may be working on a much longer clock than either of you assumed.
Third, policy travels. San Francisco passed its own COPA in 2019. Washington, D.C. has had a tenant version since 1980. New York City now has what its sponsor calls the largest program of its kind in the country. Agents who understand the mechanics today will not be surprised if a similar proposal shows up closer to home.
Which buildings COPA covers
COPA does not touch most New York real estate. A building has to fit one of two tracks.
Track 1: Distressed buildings with four or more units
The law lists five distress measures, and a building only needs to meet one at the time it goes up for sale. The measures reported so far include:
- An annual daily average of three or more Class B or Class C housing violations per unit. Class B is "hazardous" and Class C is "immediately hazardous" under the NYC housing code.
- At least one year in the city's Alternative Enforcement Program, which targets the most troubled buildings.
- Being subject to an in rem tax foreclosure action by the city.
- A denied certificate of no harassment within the prior year, without later remediation.
Track 2: Smaller regulated buildings
Buildings with 100 or fewer units that are under affordability (regulatory) agreements managed by HPD.
What is not covered
- One- to three-family homes.
- Qualifying condominium and cooperative conversions.
- Large mixed-income and affordable buildings that use as-of-right tax abatements such as 485-x and 421-a, or city zoning enhancements.
- Any multifamily building that does not meet a distress measure and has no HPD agreement.
On the number of buildings: the City Council cited about 2,100, down from roughly 10,000 under earlier drafts. HPD's own estimate is about 3,400. Advocates expect around 300 covered sales a year. Use the range, not a single figure.
How a COPA sale works, step by step
- Owner gives notice. Before marketing or selling a covered building, the owner notifies HPD. HPD is building an online portal for these notices and will publish the list of approved buyers ("qualified entities").
- 20 days: statement of interest. A qualified entity tells the owner and HPD that it intends to pursue the building. If none does, the right of first offer is waived and the owner can go to market.
- 70 days: the offer. An interested entity submits its offer. Extensions are capped at five days.
- 10 days: owner responds. The owner accepts, rejects, or counters. The owner is never required to accept.
- 30 days: contract. If the offer is accepted or countered, the parties have 30 days to sign a contract of sale.
- 15 days: right of first refusal. If the owner rejects the offer and, within one year, decides to accept an outside offer, the owner must notify HPD and the entity that made the first offer. That entity has 15 days to match on identical terms. If it declines, or matches and fails to close, the owner has no further COPA obligation.
Add it up and the maximum window is about 145 days. The Council shortened it from 160 days in response to industry concerns.
Enforcement
HPD can seek a civil penalty of up to 15% of the sale price. Qualified entities can also sue the owner directly, and they have two years from the date the deed is publicly recorded to do so. That two-year tail is a title and closing issue, not only a seller issue.
Case studies and examples
The East Harlem portfolio that went to auction the day COPA was signed
A 38-building portfolio in East Harlem, about 850 mostly rent-stabilized apartments, once owned by Emerald Equities, headed to foreclosure auctions the same day the mayor signed COPA. Emerald bought the buildings for $350 million in 2016. Lenders foreclosed in 2024 and the company filed for bankruptcy in 2025. The buildings carried more than 2,300 housing code violations as of April 2026.
Spatial Equity, an affordable housing developer backed by City Hall, tried to buy the portfolio. Lenders turned down a $68 million bid and, according to a tenant leader, a later $110 million offer.
Many notices, few closings
San Francisco's COPA covers buildings with three or more units. Sellers give qualified nonprofits a five-day notice, and an interested nonprofit has 25 days to make an offer. In roughly the first seven months, nonprofits received more than 150 notices and put only seven properties under contract. A 2023 report by LISC credits the program with preserving about 230 units since 2019.
A purchase-right law that was later narrowed
D.C.'s Tenant Opportunity to Purchase Act (TOPA) gives tenants, not nonprofits, the first right. Combined with preservation funding, it has developed or preserved more than 16,000 affordable units since 2006. Investors, however, cited delay and uncertainty as reasons to avoid the District. In 2025 the D.C. Council passed the RENTAL Act, effective December 31, 2025, which added exemptions, including one for multifamily buildings during the 15 years after their certificate of occupancy.
The violation math on a 24-unit building
A 24-unit walk-up in the Bronx averages 80 open Class B and C violations across the year. Divide 80 by 24 and you get 3.3 per unit, above the threshold of three. The building is covered. At an average of 60 violations, the figure is 2.5 per unit and the building falls outside that particular test.
The New York seller who wants to exchange into South Florida
An investor based in Bogotá owns a 12-unit building in Queens and wants to sell it and buy a small multifamily property in Broward through a 1031 exchange. If the Queens building is covered, the owner may spend up to 145 days in the COPA process before a contract with an outside buyer is secure.
The 45-day identification period and 180-day exchange period start when the relinquished property closes, so COPA does not shorten those deadlines for this seller. What it changes is when the clock starts, and how predictable that start date is. The reverse situation is harder: a buyer inside an active exchange who targets a covered building as the replacement property may run out of time.
What skipping the notice can cost
An owner sells a covered building for $6,000,000 without going through COPA. The civil penalty can reach 15% of the price, which is $900,000. Separately, a qualified entity can sue for up to two years after the deed is recorded.
How COPA compares to similar laws
| New York City COPA | San Francisco COPA | Washington, D.C. TOPA | Florida | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds the right | HPD-approved nonprofits and certain joint ventures | City-qualified nonprofits | Tenants | No equivalent for apartment buildings |
| Buildings covered | 4+ units and distressed, or 100 or fewer units with HPD agreements | 3+ residential units | Rental housing, with exemptions added in 2025 | Mobile home parks only (Chapter 723, Florida Statutes) |
| First window | 20 days to express interest, 70 days to offer | 5-day notice, 25 days to offer | Varies by building type | Not applicable |
| Match right | 15 days, within one year of a rejected offer | Yes, right of first refusal | Yes | Not applicable |
| Status | Signed Nov. 10, 2026; effective about Nov. 2027 | In effect since 2019 | In effect since 1980; amended Dec. 31, 2025 | No pending equivalent known |
No. If your building is covered, you have to notify the city and give approved nonprofits time to make an offer first. You can say no. If you later accept another buyer's offer within a year, the nonprofit that offered first gets 15 days to match it.
Your COPA action plan: how to prepare and where the business is
The law gives the industry roughly twelve months of lead time. Professionals who use that year will be the ones clients call when it takes effect. Here is a working plan.
This week
- Correct the record with your database. Send a short note to every client with New York ties. Three facts: signed, not yet in effect; New York City only; four or more units and distressed. Most of what they have seen online is missing at least one of the three.
- Tag your CRM. Create a tag such as "NY property owner" and apply it to every contact who owns, inherited, or manages New York real estate. This is your follow-up list for the next year.
- Ask three questions. How many units? Is there an HPD regulatory agreement? How many open Class B and C violations? Those three answers tell you whether to keep going.
"COPA was signed on November 10, 2026 and takes effect about a year later. It only covers certain distressed New York City apartment buildings with four or more units. If you own one, let's check whether yours is covered before you plan a sale."
Next 30 days
- Line up a New York referral partner. Find one or two New York-licensed brokers who sell multifamily property and put a written referral agreement in place through your broker. A referral you can make in one phone call is worth more than one you have to research under pressure.
- Run the coverage check. For each client building, have the owner or their New York team pull the violation record on HPD Online. Divide the open Class B and C violations by the number of units. At or near three per unit, flag it.
- Add an attorney to the team. Introduce the client to a New York real estate attorney before there is a deal on the table, not after.
Next 90 days
- Build a "New York to South Florida" replacement list. Keep a current short list of exchange-suitable properties in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach: small multifamily, net-leased commercial, and income-producing residential. Refresh it monthly so you can respond the day a client decides to sell.
- Teach it. Host a 20-minute briefing for your office, your investor clients, or your sphere, in English and in Spanish. The professional who explains the law first is the one people associate with it.
- Adjust your deal structure. When a Florida purchase depends on a New York sale, write timelines and contingencies around a possible 145-day delay. Raise rate-lock periods with the lender and closing dates with the title company early.
Before November 2027
- Help owners make a timing decision. Based on the effective date, a sale that closes before the law takes effect would not go through the COPA process. Owners who were already planning to sell should review timing with their New York attorney and tax advisor. Your role is to make sure they know the date, not to push a sale.
- Track HPD. Three things are still to come: the final rules, the list of qualified entities, and the notice portal. Put a quarterly reminder on your calendar to check for updates and send your tagged contacts a short status note each time.
Where the opportunity is, by role
| If you are a... | Prepare by | Opportunity |
|---|---|---|
| Florida agent or broker | Tagging New York owners, building a referral partner and a replacement-property list | Referral fees on New York sales and the purchase side when that capital lands in South Florida |
| New York listing broker | Offering a pre-listing coverage and violation review; getting to know the nonprofits likely to qualify | Qualified entities are buyers. Brokers who know them can bring sellers a real offer inside the window instead of waiting it out |
| Investor or buyer's representative | Studying the right of first refusal before spending on due diligence; exploring nonprofit partnerships | Reporting indicates qualified groups may include private developers with a nonprofit partner. HPD's rules will define who qualifies |
| Property manager | Measuring violations per unit monthly for every building managed | Keeping a building under the three-per-unit average is now a result an owner can put a dollar value on |
| Lender, title agent, or attorney | Adding COPA coverage and compliance to checklists | Being the professional who catches the issue before closing, given the 15% penalty and the two-year window to sue |
Confirm directly with your broker or office administrator before acting. For any New York transaction, the client also needs a New York real estate attorney.
The debate, in fairness to both sides
Supporters, including the mayor and tenant advocates, say COPA gives mission-driven buyers a realistic window to compete for troubled buildings and keeps tenants in place. Nonprofits have said for years that they could have bought certain buildings if they had been given that kind of window.
Opponents, including small property owner groups and some brokers, say it adds delay and uncertainty, discourages conventional buyers who can close and renovate quickly, and raises property rights concerns. The Real Estate Board of New York described the final changes as targeted and practical. As an agent, your job is to explain the mechanics accurately and leave the politics to the client.
Frequently asked questions
Is COPA in effect in New York right now?
Not yet. Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed COPA on November 10, 2026, and the law takes effect one year after enactment, which points to November 2027. During that year the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) writes the rules, publishes the list of qualified buyers, and builds the online notice portal.
Does COPA apply to single-family homes, condos, or co-ops?
No. COPA applies to multifamily buildings with four or more units that meet a distress test, and to buildings with 100 or fewer units under affordability agreements managed by HPD. One- to three-family homes are outside the law, and qualifying condominium and cooperative conversions are excluded.
Does COPA force an owner to sell to a nonprofit or accept a lower price?
No. The owner can accept, reject, or counter any offer from a qualified entity. COPA controls the sequence and timing of the sale, not the price. If the owner rejects the offer and later accepts an outside offer within one year, the qualified entity can match it on identical terms within 15 days.
How much time does COPA add to a sale?
Up to about 145 days. Qualified entities get 20 days to express interest and 70 days to submit an offer. The owner then has 10 days to respond, the parties have 30 days to sign a contract, and a 15-day right of first refusal can apply to a later outside offer.
What is the penalty for skipping the COPA process?
HPD can seek a civil penalty of up to 15 percent of the sale price. Qualified entities can also sue the owner, and they have two years from the date the deed is publicly recorded to file. On a 6 million dollar sale, the penalty exposure alone reaches 900,000 dollars.
Does Florida have a law like COPA?
Florida has no COPA-style law for apartment buildings. The closest Florida concept is in Chapter 723 of the Florida Statutes, which gives mobile home park homeowners' associations a purchase right when a park is offered for sale. Confirm directly with your broker or office administrator before acting.
Know the law before your client asks
JGRES trains agents to explain rules like this one clearly, in English and Spanish, and to turn that knowledge into trust. Send a message and ask about current classes.
Message Joaquin on WhatsApp See JGRES classesSources
Facts and figures in this article are drawn from reporting and analysis published between October 22 and November 10, 2026 by The Real Deal, NY1, HousingWire, Brick Underground, and citybiz; legal summaries of Int. 905-A by Cole Schotz and IR Global; San Francisco program data reported by Bisnow; the October 2023 LISC report on COPA and TOPA; and a Jackson & Campbell summary of the D.C. RENTAL Act of 2025.
This article is for education only and is not legal, tax, or brokerage advice. COPA's implementing rules are still being written by HPD and details may change before the law takes effect. Figures reflect published reporting as of November 10, 2026. Illustrative examples are hypothetical. Confirm directly with your broker or office administrator before acting, and consult a New York real estate attorney for any New York transaction.
